Back to Insights listing

Commercial disputesThursday 30 July 2026

Court of Appeal decision on IP accounts of profits and the Court’s jurisdiction to award interest

After a four-day appeal hearing the Court of Appeal has given judgment in a number of appeals in Lufthansa v Astronics & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 964. The main appeal concerned the significant issue of the proper approach to identifying the profits derived from infringement of a patent for the purposes of the exercise identified in s.61(1)(d) of the Patents Act 1977. One of the other appeals in the case concerned interest: what jurisdiction did the court have to award interest on such profits, was such jurisdiction available in respect of the period prior to the election (i.e. the election to take profits rather than damages), and what was the principled approach to the exercise of discretion as to the interest rate to apply? The judge had awarded interest from the date of profits at US Prime rates (the sums of profits identified under the account being US$ sums). The Defendants argued that there was no jurisdiction in equity to award interest on such profits (the relevant equitable jurisdiction being, it was argued, limited to a narrower category of cases which excluded IP account of profits), that statutory interest under s.35A of the Senior Courts Act 1981 was only available from the date of election (when, it was argued, the liability as to profits became a “debt” for relevant statutory purposes), and that interest should be calculated by converting US$ sums into euro sums (and back) and applying  a euribor related rate. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on interest: it agreed with Lufthansa that interest was available both in equity and under statute and was available in either case from (at least) the date of profits; it also agreed that the Defendants’ proposed approach to interest illegitimately brought post-profit pre-judgment currency exchange rate fluctuations into the Court’s assessment.

James Walmsley represented Lufthansa on the interest appeal (with Hugo Cuddigan KC and Chris Hall from 11 South Square on the appeal as a whole), instructed by Jones Day.

Read the full judgment

People to view:

Share by: Email

Related Insights View all thought leadership

  1. Placeholder

    Recent Cases

    High Court imposes 16-month prison sentence for contempt following successful contempt trial

    Civil fraud and asset recovery, Commercial disputes

    Jessica Brooke | Tiffany Scott KC
    Tuesday 17 November 2026

    View more
  2. Placeholder

    Recent Cases

    EAD Group v Toros : Cross-border cooperation in s.25 injunctions in aid of foreign proceedings

    Civil fraud and asset recovery, Commercial disputes, International / offshore

    Graeme Halkerston | Theo Dixon
    Monday 16 November 2026

    View more
  3. Placeholder

    Articles

    Foreign judgments and issue estoppel: orthodoxy reasserted

    In the latest edition of our commercial litigation insights series, Andreas Giannakopoulos examines the Court of Appeal's recent decision in Aviator LLC v Spribe OÜ [2026] EWCA Civ 1224, considering whether the preclusive effect of a foreign judgment on a claim made in subsequent English proceedings is governed by English law or the law applicable to the underlying claim.

    By Andreas Giannakopoulos
    Wednesday 28 October 2026

    View more
  4. Placeholder

    News

    Clare Stanley KC featured in Chambers & Partners Stars at the Bar 2027

    Clare Stanley KC has been named as one of Chambers’ Stars at the Bar, an accolade given to just 16 top barristers who are recognised for their excellence across a range of practice areas. Clare is ranked by Chambers &... Read more

    Tuesday 27 October 2026

    View more

View all thought leadership