Back to Insights listing

PropertyMonday 11 May 2026

90 Year Lease or Contractual Licence?

On 8 May 2026, judgment was handed down in Quadrant-Brownswood Tenant Co-operative Ltd v Hitchens, an interesting possession claim in the County Court at Clerkenwell and Shoreditch.

The backdrop to the decision is the rule that a tenancy must be for a certain term. An occupancy agreement conferring exclusive possession cannot give rise to a tenancy if its duration is not certain at the outset; equally a periodic arrangement cannot be a tenancy if there is a fetter of uncertain duration on the giving of a notice to quit. In Mexfield Housing Limited v Berrisford [2012] 1 AC 955, the Supreme Court held that where such an agreement was entered into with an individual (as opposed to a company), it was one which the common law would have treated as a lease for life and which is converted into a 90-year term by s.149(6) of the Law of Property Act 1925. However, in Southward Housing Co-operative v Walker [2015] EWHC 1615, Hildyard J held that the Mexfield analysis could be disapplied where there was a clear contrary intention. In that case, the parties had attempted to create a weekly tenancy but the landlord could only serve a notice to quit in limited circumstances. It was decided that the Defendant occupied under a contractual licence, that more closely reflecting the parties’ intentions than a 90-year lease.

As in both Mexfield and Southward, in Quadrant-Brownswood, the Defendant was a member of a fully-mutual housing co-operative. The District Judge, following Southward, held that Ms Hitchens had only a contractual licence to occupy the home she had lived in for 26 years. The Senior Circuit Judge, His Honour Judge Richard Roberts, allowed Ms Hitchen’s appeal from the possession order. He held that on the proper construction of Ms Hitchens’ agreement, she had an express tenancy for life, which was converted into a 90-year lease, or contract therefor, under s.149(6).

These issues are particularly likely to affect mutual housing co-operatives and their members, since their arrangements are likely to be intended for the long term but do not benefit from statutory security of tenure.

Joanne Wicks KC acted pro bono for Ms Hitchens through Advocate; instructed by Kennedys LLP, also acting pro bono through Pro Bono Connect.

Read the full judgment

People to view:

Share by: Email

Related Insights View all thought leadership

  1. Placeholder

    External Conferences

    Arbrix 2026 Conference

    Wednesday 18 November 2026
    Stratford Manor Hotel, Warwick Road, Stratford-upon-Avon

    View more
  2. Placeholder

    Articles

    Real property, real impact: throwing off mediaeval chains or heresy?

    Article by Harriet Holmes, published 28th September 2026 This article was originally published by Estates Gazette here. Manchester Airport v Dutton [1999] EWCA Civ 844; [1999] 1 EGLR 147 may have been decided shortly before the turn of the century, but in... Read more

    By Harriet Holmes
    Monday 26 October 2026

    View more
  3. Placeholder

    Articles

    Real property, real impact: the ground (f) questions left by Franses

    Article by Benjamin Faulkner and Francesca Mitchell, published 28th September 2026 This article was originally published by Estates Gazette here. It used to be said that ground (f) cases under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 were a landlord’s to lose.... Read more

    By Benjamin Faulkner | Francesca Mitchell
    Monday 28 September 2026

    View more
  4. Placeholder

    Recent Cases

    High Court dismisses appeal against non-party costs order based on personal and family interests in litigation

    Property

    Joanne Wicks KC
    Monday 7 September 2026

    View more

View all thought leadership