Back to Insights listing

Banking and financial services, Commercial disputes, International / offshoreTuesday 17 October 2023

DIFC Court rejects $18.5 million damages claim in Kirtanlal International DMCC v State Bank Of India (DIFC Branch)

Judgment has been handed down in the Court of First Instance of the DIFC by Justice Sir Jeremy Cooke.

Kirtanlal International DMCC (“Kirtanlal”), a steel trading company, brought a claim for damages of USD 18.51m in relation to what it said was the unlawful termination of its facility agreement with the Defendant bank (the “Bank”). Kirtanlal claimed that the Bank acted in breach of a duty of good faith and/or a Braganza duty, alleging malice on the part of the Bank. Kirtanlal also alleged that there were breaches of tortious, fiduciary and regulatory duties by the Bank.

The Claim was dismissed.

The claims in tort, fiduciary duty and regulatory duty were abandoned by Kirtanlal in closing submissions. The Claim in contract was rejected by the Court, as it held that the Bank was entitled to terminate the contract when it did.

The Court held that there was no duty of good faith or Braganza duty implied into the contract between the Bank and Kirtanlal, but that, in any case, the Bank’s decision was not only “rational but also reasonable” such that there would have been no breach of any such duty even if it existed.

In so finding, the Court rejected the assertions made that the Bank or its witnesses had acted in bad faith or with malice. However, the three witnesses tendered by Kirtanlal were all described by the Court as “dishonest” in their evidence.

In addition, the Court held that the Claim would have failed on the basis of causation and loss, with the Court concluding that there was “no basis on which it can properly be said that Kirtanlal suffered any loss at all from the suspension or termination of the SBI facilities, let alone any evidence of any such loss and damage which the Court could regard as established with a reasonable degree of certainty on the balance of probabilities for the purposes of Article 11 of the Damages Law”.

The judgment contains an interesting discussion in particular of the principles concerning good faith and the Braganza duty as a matter of DIFC Law, including in relation to Articles 57 and 58 of the Contract Law.

Bobby Friedman, together with David Holloway of Al-Tamimi & Company, acted successfully for the Bank.

Read the full judgment

People to view:

Share by: Email

Related Insights View all thought leadership

  1. Placeholder

    Recent Cases

    EAD Group v Toros : Cross-border cooperation in s.25 injunctions in aid of foreign proceedings

    Civil fraud and asset recovery, Commercial disputes, International / offshore

    Graeme Halkerston | Theo Dixon
    Monday 16 November 2026

    View more
  2. Placeholder

    Articles

    Foreign judgments and issue estoppel: orthodoxy reasserted

    In the latest edition of our commercial litigation insights series, Andreas Giannakopoulos examines the Court of Appeal's recent decision in Aviator LLC v Spribe OÜ [2026] EWCA Civ 1224, considering whether the preclusive effect of a foreign judgment on a claim made in subsequent English proceedings is governed by English law or the law applicable to the underlying claim.

    By Andreas Giannakopoulos
    Wednesday 28 October 2026

    View more
  3. Placeholder

    News

    Clare Stanley KC featured in Chambers & Partners Stars at the Bar 2027

    Clare Stanley KC has been named as one of Chambers’ Stars at the Bar, an accolade given to just 16 top barristers who are recognised for their excellence across a range of practice areas. Clare is ranked by Chambers &... Read more

    Tuesday 27 October 2026

    View more
  4. Placeholder

    Articles

    A fiduciary’s duty to disclose: a shield, not a sword?

    In this article in our commercial litigation insights series, Alice Hawker examines the Court of Appeal's recent decision in G.I. Globinvestment Ltd v XY ERS UK Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 1248, considering whether a fiduciary's duty to disclose is a shield (against claims alleging breach of the ’no conflict’ or ’no profit’ rules) or a sword (to be used as a freestanding claim).

    By Alice Hawker
    Monday 19 October 2026

    View more

View all thought leadership